Consumer Reports takes a look at cell phone based GPS

Consumer Reports takes a look at cell phone based GPS

GPS was a huge gift this year for the holidays.' CR noticed GPS via cell phone is starting to become a bigger player and decided to dig into if the hype lives up.' Cell phone GPS allow you to eliminate a standalone device and turn your phone into an accurate, voice-enabled navigation device.' CR uncovered several pros and cons and as an avid GPS industry observer, I’ll add my two cents as well.

Many smart phones these days such as BlackBerry’s, Samsung Instinct, iPhone, etc. come with GPS capabilities, a useful feature. The facts: cell phone GPS usually costs either $3 a day per usage or $10 a month, which isn’t too bad, but standalone units are free, of course.' Some phones also come with traffic information, a good feature that is also present in standalone units.' Now, they also offer turn-by-turn directions so you don’t have to look at the small phone screen.' However, standalone units offer this too and their screens are generally big - 3.5 inches to 5 inches are common sizes.' I like looking at my GPS screen even if it is speaking out turn-by-turn directions.' In addition, standalone GPS speakers are specifically meant for clarity and spoken directions, while cell phone speakers aren’t necessarily the best.' Also, not all cellphones such as the G1 and the iPhone offer turn-by-turn directions.

CR finds that cell phone based GPS is good if you travel a lot with your cell phone, because it would be better than to lug around a GPS.' It is very possible to have a standalone GPS unit stolen or lost because they are pretty small and coveted electronics, but you will always have your cell phone with you.' CR also reports that cell phones such as the Instinct and the Glyde that come with big screens and QWERTY keyboards are more beneficial to use.'

Lastly, CR says that GPS subscription costs can end up costing you the same amount as a standalone unit.' At this point, you probably are better off getting a standalone unit because you can travel with it easily, give it to a family member when they go someplace and it won’t drain your cell phone battery.' Personally, I would recommend getting a standalone unit if you travel a lot even if you do have a cell phone with GPS capabilities, however, if you travel often for business then a cell phone should do the job.

For more information on GPSs and what is good for you, check out Gagetell’s Buying Guide for GPSs.

Read [9News]